Due to a series of unfortunate events, a Sun Prairie icon for over 40 years had closed...leaving yet another hole in the list of full service, supper club dining experiences. It was remembered for it's quality of food, excellent service and amazing salad bar!
We were SO HAPPY to learn that it was re-opening (under new ownership) this past fall and finally made it there this month to see how it stacked up.
On a scale of 1 to 10... we'd give it a 3.
We went with our three year old, who does VERY well when out and were instantly charmed by the host as he played up to her.
We sat at our table for 10 minutes before someone came over to take our order...and waited longer for our drinks to come back (how tough is it to pour a soda?)
The children's menu was sad -- nothing on it that wasn't fried...hasn't anyone heard of the childhood obesity epidemic?? SOOO, we decided to share our real food with her.
When looking at the adult menu, it was painfully obvious that someone needed to spellcheck it for them - even the printer should have caught how one word was mis-spelled 2 different ways.
Migon....Minon. I didn't think I wanted a fillet of that, not for over $20. Let's talk some more about that menu? What supper club doesn't have baked potatoes?? "Only on weekends" was the answer we got...leaving us with french fries, hashbrowns or mashed potatoes. No sight of the famous potato pancakes they used to offer.
So we order, and hit the salad bar. Keep in mind that this place was legendary for it's salad bar offerings -- variety and freshness. My hubby had the spinach salad with hot dressing. Here's a tip to whoever makes it...it should have some SUGAR in it. Hot bacon vinegar on spinach isn't quite right. He also got cruchy breadsticks to go with the pate he loves. Guess what? They weren't stale, they were RANCID. We guessed that they were leftover from the original owners (it's been closed over a year...)
Dinner came -- his Shrimp dinner looked fine, I had pork chops with apple cranberrry sauce. The sauce came on the side, and it was a good thing -- it was a bordelaise sauce (think au jus with onion and mushroom) with a tad of chopped up apple in it (maybe 4 small chunks). The mashed potatoes were slim in offerings and the hash browns were slightly burnt. Disappointing.
No refills on beverages, no offer of dessert...which led us to think that they were understaffed.
It still came to over $40 with our coupon. Save your money and try a chain like Texas Roadhouse instead -- it's a very short drive into Madison, and you can get a steak dinner for under $10. They have baked potatoes.